Empowering compassionate teaching
Meditation Related Challenges (MRCs) are not new; they've been noted in ancient Pali texts and various contemplative traditions over centuries. However, the surge in mindfulness courses and apps means many teachers are unaware of how to identify and address worrisome participant experiences, often stopping at trauma awareness. At Meditators in Distress UK, we believe all teachers want to offer their best. It's our ethical and compassionate obligation to inform ourselves on these matters, fostering a no-blame approach to support both teachers and meditators.
Essential insights for facilitators
Gain crucial knowledge to enhance your teaching practice. We provide clear information on what constitutes a meditation challenge, effective prevention strategies, and how to compassionately support those who experience them. This section offers practical guidance to equip you with confidence and understanding.
What is a meditation challenge?
Understand the nature of Meditation Related Challenges (MRCs), distinguishing between typical discomfort and potentially worrisome experiences. Learn to recognise the signs and symptoms.
Institutional Betrayal
Many teachers and organisations have little or no training in how to help people who experience challenges, often being trained to give advice which may be actively harmful. When someone is already destabilised they may need to back off or slow down. Passing on advice which you can see is not helpful can lead to guilt, feelings of failure etc in the facilitator.
Supporting your students
Learn practical approaches for responding effectively when a participant experiences distress. Gain insight into how to offer appropriate support and guidance.
Cultivating confident, compassionate facilitators
We want you to feel proud of the teachings you offer and of your commitment to being as well-informed and compassionate as possible. The unexpected may always occur, but being prepared means you're not left wondering if more could have been done. This approach is a win-win for everyone involved in meditation practice.
Why Meditators in Distress UK?
It is incredibly challenging to find comprehensive resources and conversations about Meditation Related Challenges (MRCs). Meditators in Distress UK fills this crucial gap, offering essential information and guidance that is often overlooked in standard teacher training, which typically stops at trauma awareness.
Our commitment to you
Meditators in Distress UK is dedicated to providing vital information, specialized training, and ongoing support. We cater not only to meditators experiencing distress but also to meditation teachers, facilitators, and retreat leaders, empowering you to navigate complex situations with confidence and care.
Table of expected vs unusual experience. See also the VCE report. (this section is under construction)
| Typical and Usual - not of concern. | Unusual, persistant, or distressing - needing action and advice. |
|---|---|
| There are many distractions and experiences which can happen depending on an individual, the form and method of meditating as well as cultural and environmental factors. These should be taken into account when considering any experience reported. | Any experience which the person feels powerless to change, or as if they are being controlled, any impulse of mind which they feel unable to resist should be responded too immediately and advice given to stop all Practice. |
| Jumpy, itchy, having an urge to move or change position, this can be so strong as to be a distraction. | Unusual movement or feeling like movement is not under persons control. |
| A bit spacy, blissed out, slightly out of touch or a little numb. | Being spacy, blissed out numb etc that is unplesant and persists beyond the period of meditation or that returns unbidden when not practicing. |
| Surges of energy in the body or up and down the spine, twinkling at the edges of vision, very bright light or colours either seen or experienced in the mind. | Uncontrolable surges of energy that are frightening in intensity and wont go away or prevent rest. Feeling like some kind of energetic force is in control. |
Q&A for Teachers, retreat leaders and facilitators.
According to research are there specific Practices associated with a greater risk of someone experiencing an adverse effect? Yes!
- Any practice longer than 30 mins.
- Insistence on immobility during long practices.
- Body Scan and Breath based practices.
- Those in which the focus is on 'no-self', dissolution of the ego, and those with an emphasis on exploration of 'who is this observer/where is this observer' and who is this self.
- Practices that insist on use of decentred language, avoiding use of me, mine, your etc and replacing this with 'the' . e.g. 'the body' replacing 'your body' in practice guidance.
Are there any circumstances in which participants are at higher risk?
Research indicates that certain forms of retreats and practices within them are high risk.
- Silent retreats in which connection with other's is banned. One of the ways humans naturally regulate emotion is through co-regulation with others. On some retreats one is not supposed to even make eye contact with another person. If someone is experiencing high emotional arousal with no opportunity for co regulation with others this can lead to severe adverse effects.
- Food restriction. Again research indicates that a sudden change in eating habits (meal frequency, change from meat eating to vegan, and restrictive calorie intake) can precipitate adverse effects. Nutrient dense food such as meat is very grounding to the human organism so if someone becomes ungrounded in practice, eating nutrient dense food can help. In retreats where meat is not served this grounding does not happen. In addition many retreat traditions are inflexible in permitting adaptations, further exacerbating the situation.
- Some lineage traditions are very inflexible in their interpretation of and adaptation too adverse effects, insisting on a POV that is known to be risky once an adverse effect has occurred. Telling people that what they are experiencing is normal, refusing to make adaptations for people who are suffering, and giving unhelpful advice such as to keep up with or even increase the very practices that are causing distress. This then becomes harm and/or trauma.
More generally teachers should pay attention to the environment in which they are teaching. The use of church halls, Buddhist or other centres based on specific religion or life path system should be avoided unless it is clear one is teaching from/within such a tradition or lineage. Teachers offering secular meditation need to avoid such venues completely and offer sessions in a neutral space free of icons, images or materials to the contrary.
Teachers need to understand the lineage of the programme or system they are offering in order to avoid moral injury. MBSR and all courses and curriculums based on it are in fact founded on transmitting Buddhist dharma.
Create Your Own Website With Webador